AI Link building agency nofollow vs follow — When each matters; natural patterns.

For the last twenty years, the SEO (keresőoptimalizálás) industry has been obsessed with a single attribute of HTML code: rel="dofollow".

In the traditional model, a "dofollow" link was gold—it passed "Link Juice" (PageRank) from one site to another, directly influencing rankings. A "nofollow" link was often considered worthless—a dead end that passed no authority.

However, as we transition to an internet dominated by Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative Search (like ChatGPT Search, Google AI Overviews, and Perplexity), this binary distinction is rapidly becoming obsolete. AI does not just count "juice"; it reads context, it tracks user behavior, and it analyzes "Brand Entities."

In the AI era, a "nofollow" link can be just as powerful as a "dofollow" link, provided it appears in the right semantic context.

This article explores the new physics of link building, explaining why an AI Link Building Agency must abandon the "dofollow or nothing" mindset to build a natural, future-proof profile.

Part I: The Technical Distinction (and why it’s fading)

To understand the future, we must quickly revisit the definitions that governed the past.

1. The Dofollow Link

• Definition: A standard hyperlink without any restrictions.

• Traditional Function: It tells search engine crawlers, "I trust this target site. Transfer some of my authority (PageRank) to them."

• AI Function: It remains the strongest signal of direct endorsement and authority transfer.

2. The Nofollow Link (rel="nofollow")

• Definition: An attribute added to the link tag (<a href="..." rel="nofollow">).

• Traditional Function: It tells crawlers, "I am linking to this page for utility, but I do not vouch for it technically. Do not pass PageRank."

• AI Function: It serves as a Citation. While it may not pass mathematical "authority," it passes Information Gain.

3. The Modern Variants (rel="ugc", rel="sponsored")

Google introduced these to further categorize nofollow links. ugc (User Generated Content) is for forums/comments; sponsored is for paid placements. AI models use these tags to understand the nature of the relationship between the two entities.

The Paradigm Shift:

In traditional SEO (keresőoptimalizálás), the algorithm counted votes.

In AI Search, the model builds a Knowledge Graph.

A "nofollow" link from a highly trusted source (like Wikipedia or a major news outlet) still connects two nodes in the Knowledge Graph. It tells the AI: "Entity A is related to Entity B."

Part II: Why AI Models Value "Nofollow" Links

If an LLM like GPT-4 or Gemini is crawling the web to learn about a topic, it is reading the text, not just the metadata.

1. The "Mention" is the new "Link"

LLMs function on Semantic Proximity. If the New York Times writes an article about data privacy and mentions your brand, but uses a nofollow link (or no link at all), the AI still reads the text.

It associates your Brand Vector with the topic "Data Privacy."

• The AI Logic: "This high-authority text discusses [Brand X] in the context of [Topic Y]. Therefore, there is a probability that [Brand X] is relevant to [Topic Y]."

• The nofollow tag prevents the transfer of raw ranking power, but it does not prevent the transfer of topical relevance.

2. Traffic as a Validator

Google’s AI algorithms (like Navboost) and modern LLMs rely heavily on user interaction data.

• Scenario: You get a nofollow link on a high-traffic Reddit thread.

• Outcome: 500 real humans click that link and spend 5 minutes on your site.

• The Signal: The AI observes this traffic. It sees high engagement. It concludes that your site satisfies user intent.

• The Result: Your organic rankings improve despite the link being nofollow, because the user behavior validated the link.

3. Trust via Curation

Search engines know that "dofollow" links are often bought and sold (manipulated).

"Nofollow" links, especially those on Wikipedia, major news sites (Forbes, CNN), and strict social platforms, are often harder to manipulate.

Therefore, a link profile that contains only dofollow links looks suspicious to an AI. It looks like a "Link Scheme."

A profile rich in "nofollow" links signals natural editorial interest.

Part III: The "Natural" Link Profile

An AI Link Building Agency is essentially a "Pattern Matching" agency. The goal is to match the pattern of a legitimate, viral brand.

What does a natural profile look like? It is messy. It is chaotic. It is full of nofollow links.

The Entropy of Linking

If you analyze the backlink profile of a major brand (e.g., Amazon, Slack, or a local government site), you will usually find a ratio closer to:

• 60% Dofollow

• 40% Nofollow (including UGC/Sponsored)

If your agency builds a profile that is 99% Dofollow, you have created a statistical anomaly.

• AI Detection: The AI compares your site's "Link Entropy" against the average for your industry.

• The Penalty: If you deviate too far from the natural mean, the AI flags your profile as "Artificial." Your links lose their potency.

The "Wikipedia" Paradox

Wikipedia is one of the most trusted sites on the internet. Every external link on Wikipedia is rel="nofollow".

Does this mean a Wikipedia link is useless? Absolutely not.

• Entity Verification: A link from Wikipedia validates your existence as a notable entity.

• Knowledge Graph: It directly feeds the Google Knowledge Graph.

• AI Confidence: When an AI sees a Wikipedia citation, its "Confidence Score" regarding facts about your business increases dramatically.

Strategic Takeaway: You should actively seek nofollow links from "Seed Sites" (authoritative directories, wikis, major news aggregators) to build the trust layer of your foundation.

Part IV: Traffic vs. Juice — The New ROI

In the past, clients paid agencies for "Domain Authority (DA)" increases. Today, they should pay for "Referral Traffic" and "Citation Flow."

The "Referral" Value

A dofollow link on a blog that gets 0 visitors is worth effectively nothing in the AI era.

A nofollow link on a specialized industry newsletter that gets 10,000 readers is priceless.

Why?

Because AI Search is moving towards Personalization.

If a user clicks a nofollow link from a newsletter to your site, their browser history records that interaction.

Next time that specific user asks ChatGPT or Google about a related topic, the AI is more likely to surface your site because it knows the user has interacted with it before.

Nofollow links are the primary drivers of this user-history data.

Part V: Case Study — The "Firkabox" Strategy

Let’s apply this to our specific brand example: Az Adatvédelem Mesterfogásai: iratmegsemmisítő firkabox.hu.

(The Tricks of Data Protection: document shredder firkabox.hu).

We are trying to position Firkabox as the leader in secure document destruction.

1. The "Dofollow" Campaign (The Power)

We need dofollow links to push the keyword rankings for "iratmegsemmisítő".

• Tactics: Guest posts on office management blogs, business logistics sites, and green recycling tech journals.

• Goal: Pass technical authority to the domain so it can compete for head terms.

2. The "Nofollow" Campaign (The Trust & Traffic)

We need nofollow links to prove to the AI that Firkabox is a real business discussed by real people.

• Social Media (UGC/Nofollow): We create a campaign on LinkedIn discussing GDPR fines. The links back to the site are nofollow, but the engagement signals relevance.

• Press Releases (Nofollow): We issue a press release: "Firkabox launches new micro-cut technology." These links are usually nofollow. However, the text gets syndicated to 300 news sites. The AI reads this massive duplication of the brand name and associates it with "micro-cut technology."

• Wikipedia/Wikidata: We attempt to get Firkabox cited as a source on a page about "Information Destruction." The link is nofollow, but it cements the brand as a reference source.

• Quora/Reddit: We answer questions about "how to shred tax documents." The links are nofollow. But they generate highly qualified clicks from users looking for a solution right now.

The Synergy:

The Dofollow links provide the fuel (power).

The Nofollow links provide the steering (context) and the wheels (traffic).

Without the nofollow links, the dofollow links look suspicious.

Part VI: How AI Search Engines (Perplexity, SearchGPT) Cite Sources

This is the frontier of SEO (keresőoptimalizálás). How do the new AI engines decide what to cite in their answers?

1. The "Citation Probability" Score

When you ask Perplexity a question, it runs a RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) process.

It retrieves top documents. It reads them. It synthesizes an answer.

It cites the documents that provided the Information Gain.

Does Perplexity care if the link to your site was nofollow?

Generally, No.

Perplexity cares about the content on your page. If your page has the best answer, Perplexity will cite it.

However, to get found by Perplexity, you need to be in its index (or Bing's index). Traditional ranking factors (boosted by dofollow links) help you get into the pool of documents that Perplexity considers.

But once you are in that pool, the rel="nofollow" tag is largely irrelevant to whether the AI cites you. It is the quality of your information that earns the AI citation.

2. Brand Positioning in AI

If you have extensive nofollow coverage on high-tier news sites (e.g., a mention in The Guardian or TechCrunch), the AI's training data associates your brand with "High Prestige."

When generating an answer for "Top Premium Shredding Services," the AI is more likely to include Firkabox because its vector embedding sits close to "Premium" and "Trusted News," even if those connections were built via nofollow links.

Part VII: Agency Strategy — Selling the "Mix"

The hardest part of being an AI Link Building Agency is explaining to a client why you spent time getting a "nofollow" link.

The Pitch:

"We are not just building links for Google's algorithm of 2015. We are building a Digital Footprint for the AI models of 2025.

A 'dofollow' link increases your Score.

A 'nofollow' link increases your Visibility and Traffic.

You cannot rank if you are not visible. We build a 60/40 mix to ensure your growth looks organic and protects you from spam updates, while feeding the AI the traffic signals it craves."

The "Link Velocity" Safety Valve

Nofollow links act as a safety valve for Link Velocity.

If you want to grow fast, you cannot build 100 dofollow links in a month for a new site. You will get penalized.

But you can build 20 dofollow links and 80 nofollow links (citations, social shares, press).

This allows you to be "noisy" and grow your brand awareness rapidly without tripping the "SpamBrain" wire.

Conclusion

The war between "dofollow" and "nofollow" is a relic of the keyword-stuffing era.

In the era of Semantic Search and AI, the focus must shift to "Link Utility."

• Is the link useful to the user?

• Does the link drive relevant traffic?

• Does the link appear in a context that reinforces the Brand Entity?

If the answer is yes, the HTML attribute rel="nofollow" is a minor technicality.

For Firkabox and other forward-thinking brands, the strategy is Total Visibility. An AI Link Building Agency must cast a wide net, capturing authority where possible, but never fearing the "nofollow" tag if it brings traffic, trust, and truth.

The natural pattern of the web is a mix. To win in AI search, you must mimic nature, not a spreadsheet.

Summary: The AI Link Attribute Matrix

AttributePrimary Value in Old SEO (keresőoptimalizálás)Primary Value in AI SearchOptimal StrategyDofollowRanking Power (Link Juice)Authority & Indexing PriorityUse for "Money Keywords" & Core RankingNofollowNone (wasted effort)Traffic, Trust, & Entity AssociationUse for PR, News, Wikipedia, High-Traffic sourcesUGCSpam preventionUser Sentiment AnalysisUse for Forum/Community presence (Reddit/Quora)SponsoredComplianceCommercial Intent SignalUse for clear advertisements; AI knows this is "paid"

Copyright Masszázs